http://museum-security.org/
securma@xs4all.nl
SITE MAP

September 28, 1999
CONTENTS:
- Stolen Public Art (Jennifer Barrett)
- Newton's library sold to US in secret deal
- STOLEN' ART WORKS UP FOR SALE
- Guidelines for the Security of Rare Book, Manuscript, and other Special Collections
- Windsor Castle Fire Contained
- War, the pressures of tourism and Russian corruption are the most serious problems facing the world's greatest buildings and historic sites
- Beetles Destroy Gallery Carpet (gallery had to be shut down and two exhibits had to be taken apart)
- The race for riches; Under the sea, treasure hunters and scientists battle for history's bounty
From: JBJPLAN@aol.com
Subject: Stolen Public Art
Have any of your Museum Security Network participants encountered situtations where public art, like sculptures and paintings, owned by cities and jurisdictions have been stolen? I'd like to hear about such events and also about how cities and jurisdictions that have public art can protect their works.
Thanks.
Jennifer Barrett
Newton's library sold to US in secret deal
Sunday Times London
A SECRET deal between Keele University and a book dealer has resulted in Sir Isaac Newton's private library and some of his original manuscripts being exported to America, writes Jonathan Leake. The deal has infuriated Chris Smith, the culture secretary, who has ordered officials to draw up new rules to control the export of historic books and artefacts. Keele was bequeathed England's leading collection of old mathematics and physics books in 1968 by Charles Turner. But last year a private meeting of the university's council decided to sell it for UKP1m to raise money for computing facilities. The collection was sold to America earlier this year by the book dealer Simon Finch. Newton discovered the rules governing gravity and the motion of planets. The collection included eight books from his library, complete with annotations showing he used them to help produce Principia Mathematica, his major work. Three first editions of Principia are included in the collection. This weekend, the culture department confirmed they had been lost to Britain because officials had no power to halt their export.
From: UKNewsroom@aol.com
Subject: STOLEN' ART WORKS UP FOR SALE
By Chris Parkin, PA News
An art collection once stolen by one of Ireland's most notorious criminals is to be auctioned in Dublin next month. Among works going under the hammer will be Old Masters stolen by Martin Cahill, the man known as the General in Dublin's underworld, who was shot dead after crossing the IRA days before they began a ceasefire in 1994. They were the property of Alice Murnaghan, the widow of an Irish Supreme Court judge, who died earlier this year, aged 103. Mrs Murnaghan was 92 when Cahill struck at her central Dublin Georgian terraced home. He kept her and a housekeeper companion captive overnight while his gang took 50 paintings, jewellery and other art objects. The property, thought to have been stolen on behalf of a London-based criminal figure by Cahill, was all later recovered by police and returned to Mrs Murnaghan. Now the 470-lot sale is expected to fetch more than IRPound. 1.5 million when it is sold by joint auctioneers Mealy's and Christie's in Dublin on October 14. Cahill's life story has twice been filmed since his violent death - he was shot dead at the wheel of his car close to one of his Dublin houses. Apart from the Murnaghan robbery, he was well known for a series of other crimes, including a 1986 raid on an art collection at the Co Wicklow home of the late Sir Alfred Beit.
From: ewilkie@ix.netcom.com (Everett Wilkie)
Subject: Security Guidelines
I am pleased to announce that the ALA approved ACRL/RBMS "Guidelines for the Security of Rare Book, Manuscript, and other Special Collections" are now available on the RBMS web site at:
http://www.princeton.edu/~ferguson/secguide.htm
The print version will appear in a forthcoming issue of "C&RL News."
One aspect of the web version worth noting is that all the URLs and email addresses in Appendix II, which lists addresses for reporting thefts, are "active." In other words, if you need to report a theft, you may go to the web version and have the reporting mechanisms only a mouse click away. This section will be updated as circumstances require, so the RBMS Security Committee hopes to keep this section quite current between now and the next printed version, which is probably at least five years away.
I would like to thank publicly Steve Fergsuon, RBMS web master, for his help and extraordinary patience in getting this document on the section's web site.
Everett C. Wilkie, Jr.
Chair,
RBMS Security Committee
From: Jack Sullivan jacksull@mindspring.com
Subject: [Fire Safe Heritage]: Windsor Castle Fire Contained
Monday September 27 10:21 PM ET
LONDON (AP) - Fire broke out at a residence adjoining Queen Elizabeth II's castle and gutted one room before firefighters brought it under control. No injuries were reported. Windsor Castle itself was not damaged by the Sunday night blaze, which firefighters believe was started by a faulty electric blanket. The queen was at Balmoral Castle, the royal estate in Scotland, a spokesman said. In November 1992, a huge fire gutted nine of Windsor Castle's state rooms, reducing the northeast section to ashes and rubble.
War and growth of tourism are biggest threats to historic sites
By Giles Worsley
WAR, the pressures of tourism and Russian corruption are the most serious problems facing the world's greatest buildings and historic sites, according to a report published today. The World Monuments Fund's list of the 100 most endangered sites ranges from prehistoric rock carvings in Niger to a visionary arts school in Cuba built in the Sixties. Although the report was completed too early to include buildings damaged in the latest conflict in Kosovo and Serbia, the scale of devastation caused by earlier wars in Croatia, Bosnia and elsewhere in the world is clear. Among the buildings listed is the once-graceful 16th-century Ottoman bridge at Mostar in Bosnia, the destruction of which symbolised the deliberate targeting of cultural symbols during the war. The World Monuments Fund, in co-operation with the Aga Khan Trust for Culture and Unesco, is working on a complete reconstruction plan for the bridge. The report also shows how the pressures of tourism may be less dramatic but can be equally damaging. Until 1997 two lifesized carvings of giraffes dating from the sixth millennium BC on a rocky outcrop overlooking the Sahara were known only to the indigenous Tuareg people and a handful of European travellers. Widespread publicity since then means that the site is already threatened by uncontrolled visiting, despite its remoteness. In Russia, the scale of the problem means that seven sites have been included. Effective conservation is being impeded by outside cynicism about widespread corruption in the country. Colin Amery, director of the World Monuments Fund in London, said: "People almost laugh at the idea of investing in the country. There's a real atmosphere of distrust about giving funds to Russia." But according to Mr Amery, well-directed conservation in Russia can be effective: "You can do a lot in Russia really quite cheaply if you can manage it well." Several sites elsewhere in the former Soviet Union are also listed. Compared with the almost overwhelming problems faced by some countries, the United Kingdom has little excuse for its buildings being included on the list, but Mr Amery emphasises that there is no room for complacency. He cites Alexander "Greek" Thomson's magnificent St Vincent Street church in Glasgow, which was highlighted in the last report two years ago. As a result a $50,000 (UKP.30,000) grant was offered by American Express. But this has yet to be taken up and the building is still decaying. The list illustrates the remarkable pair of 13th-century barns at Faversham, Kent, owned by Wadham College, Oxford, and E W Pugin's impressive Victorian church of St Francis in Manchester. Both have been empty and unused since the Eighties and are suffering heavily from vandalism. But Britain is not alone among prosperous Western European countries in neglecting its built heritage. In France, Beauvais Cathedral, one of the masterpieces of Gothic architecture, is dangerously unstable. It is held up by a temporary tie and braces system, but this may be threatening the stability of the building. However, the report also shows how much has been achieved by the World Monuments Fund since the last list was published. This owes much to its ability to match any non-American donation dollar for dollar through the $10 million Wilson Challenge Fund. It has given grants to 60 sites in 37 countries. The results include the restoration of Brancusi's "Endless Column" in Targu Jiu in Romania and the repair of half the roof of the Alexander Palace in St Petersburg, the last home of the Tsars, which is now open to the public for the first time. Mr Amery said: "The problems are infinite but like all great heritage problems you need to start by nibbling at the edges."
(Daily Telegraph London, September 28, 1999)
Beetles Destroy Gallery Carpet
- (ORONO) --
The University of Maine at Orono estimates the cost of replacing museum carpet ruined by carpet beetles may go as high as a quarter-of-a-Million-dollars. The wool carpet in the Hudson Museum's Emerick Gallery is reportedly so infested with the critters, the gallery had to be shut down and two exhibits had to be taken apart. Museum officials say chronic dampness in the gallery is to blame for the infestation.
The race for riches; Under the sea, treasure hunters and scientists battle for history's bounty
abbreviated.
read full story at: http://www.usnews.com/usnews/issue/991004/treasure.htm
(-----------------------------------------------------)
Scientists fear that catastrophe looms behind the mad dash for wrecks, a craze regulated by murky laws. Archaeologists charge that salvors are ruining priceless "time capsules" of the deep and demand that legislators act quickly to save the planet's cultural heritage. "An archaeological project is intended to preserve and record as much scientific data as possible; a commercial salvage project is intended to make a profit," says J. Barto Arnold of the Institute of Nautical Archaeology (INA) at Texas A&M University-College Station. "Many times, treasure salvors may call themselves 'underwater archaeologists.' But would you go to an amateur brain surgeon?" Though they may lack advanced degrees, treasure hunters have unfettered access to search tools, now cheaper and more powerful than ever. Most shallow-water operations rely on magnetometers, which detect iron objects-cannons, anchors, screws-by reading the disturbances they cause in Earth's magnetic field. First developed to hunt submarines during World War II, "mags" are now sensitive enough to find tiny objects buried under layers of sand. A basic one costs around $16,000, over $10,000 less than a decade ago. Large-area, deep-water surveys often use side-scan sonars to produce acoustical snapshots of the ocean floor. Side scans, which resemble svelte torpedoes, detect objects protruding from the bottom, such as masts or hulls. Current models can map 100 square miles a day and sense objects as small as oil drums 3 miles below the surface. Instead of registering results on analog gauges, both mags and side scans now feed data into shipboard computers that correlate "hits" to global positioning system coordinates, eliminating the time-consuming, imprecise task of placing buoys over potential targets.
(-------------------------------------------)
Grave robbers? Regardless of what is recovered, many archaeologists shudder at the thought of for-profit companies tinkering with wrecks. George Bass, INA's archaeological director, has been an outspoken critic of salvors, whom he likens to grave robbers. "One cannot tear down Mount Vernon and sell the bricks as souvenirs in the name of free enterprise," he says, "so why should we allow so-called entrepreneurs to destroy and sell the nails from, say, the flagship of John Paul Jones?" Bass, currently excavating a fifth-century B.C. shipwreck near Tektas Burnu, Turkey, believes underwater archaeological sites should be accorded the same protection as, say, American Indian burial grounds. Stories of wrecks mauled and artifacts destroyed are legion in archaeological circles. Among the most notorious is the case of the DeBraak, a British warship that sank off Delaware in 1798. Salvors are said to have tossed nonglittering items back overboard, such as an 18th-century Royal Navy stove, one of only two in existence. When the ship was raised by cranes in 1986, an avalanche of artifacts slid out, falling back into the sea. "The majority of wrecks I've encountered have seen some heavy activity," says James Delgado, executive director of the Vancouver Maritime Museum. Recently visiting the brig Somers near Veracruz, Mexico, Delgado was aghast to discover that treasure hunters had pillaged the ship, which endured the only mutiny in United States naval history and inspired Herman Melville to write Billy Budd. They had ripped into the stern and looted guns, swords, and the ship's chronometer. But even the slightest misstep can ruin irreplaceable data. Cheryl Ward, an archaeobotanist at INA, collects seeds, pollen, and plant residue from ancient ships. "I've studied perfumes and spices from a shipwreck from the time of King Tut," says Ward. "I go and I look at how that perfume was used, how it shows up in economic documents and religious documents, even in paintings on walls." She worries that careless salvors simply discard these important clues to the past, since they have no value on the auction block.
( ------------------------------------------------------- )
But the Internet has allowed salvors to move treasures without museum seals of approval. Several firms now eschew auction houses in favor of selling directly to consumers. "You can literally 'own' a piece of history," reads a pitch on Mel Fisher's Treasure Hunting Site, named for the late salvor who discovered the Spanish galleon Atocha off the Florida Keys in 1985. Visitors can purchase silver coins for prices ranging between $775 and $3,000-or settle for a toothpick wrought from the Atocha's silver bars for only $45.
( ----------------------------------------------------- )
No compromise. But archaeologists remain reluctant to join forces. George Bass calls the financial argument "the big lie," pointing out that scores of archaeological projects secure funding each year. And INA's Ward believes compromise is not an option. "As soon as you start talking about selling objects, you enter the commercialization of the past," she says. "You can't stop that tide, and that's something that won't be acceptable to archaeologists. . . . We have to take the high road."
( -------------------------------------------- )
In the United States, laws governing shipwrecks are sketchy. The Abandoned Shipwreck Act of 1987 (ASA), drafted partly in response to the DeBraak debacle, granted states ownership of abandoned wrecks within 3 miles of their coasts. Yet Congress failed to define "abandonment," leading to a flurry of conflicting court decisions. The most recent case adding to the confusion concerned the Brother Jonathan. The Panama-to-Canada ferry for Gold Rush prospectors wrecked off Crescent City, Calif., in 1865; among the 223 dead were Abraham Lincoln's physician and the commander of Union troops in the West. A salvage firm, Deep Sea Research, found the vessel in 1993, and California claimed it under the ASA. Last year, the Supreme Court ruled the state had to demonstrate physical "possession" of the ship to assert ownership. The two sides settled in March, with California getting a 20 percent cut of the coins and the right to monitor future excavations.
read full story at: http://www.usnews.com/usnews/issue/991004/treasure.htm
Main Indexpage