http://museum-security.org/
securma@xs4all.nl
SITE MAP

September 11, 1999
CONTENTS:
- RE: Nazi Paintings Posting (Christopher Atkins: 'absolutely ridiculous and I am appalled that you even posted it'), and moderator's reply
- IFCPP Announcement
- Smithsonian Given Historic Asian Art Trove (world class collection of ancient Chinese artifacts, which once filled a small apartment in New Jersey, has been donated to a premier Asian art museum in Washington)
- Russians rebuilding 'Amber Chamber' known as 'Eighth Wonder of the World'
- Buddha heads roll in theft from Cambodia's ancient temples
- Rembrandt Found After Reward Raised (Reward or ransom???)
- Rare Van Gogh steps on to the open market
From: "Christopher Atkins (Museum)" CAtkins@mfa.org
To: "'Ton Cremmens'" securma@xs4all.nl
Subject: Nazi Paintings Posting
Date: Fri, 10 Sep 1999 11:19:00 -0400
Dear Ton-
My name is Christopher Atkins, a recent subscriber to your newsletter. So far I have been very pleased with the quality of writing and the appropriatness of the articles to the subject of museum security.
The newsletter that I received today had a posting from a man named Bob Smith that was absolutely ridiculous and I am appalled that you even posted it. Mr. Smith is completely out of line for suggesting that some woman with old paintings in her home has amassed a collection of paintings from Nazi war booty. His claims, evidence, and assumptions were ridiculous, and he was very disrespectful of this woman's privacy in offering this woman's address. Does he assume the "Art Police" are going to stake out this woman's house, waiting for her to move the "merchandise?"
I think that Mr. Smith has been wrapped up in the controversies surrounding many private/public collections that have come under scrutiny recently: the MFA Boston, Getty Museum, and the Seattle Art Museum to name a few. I think that it was wrong for you to take this man's story seriously.
Please respond, sincerely,
Christopher Atkins
+++++++++moderator's reply++++++++++++
Dear Christopher Atkins,
I do share your opinion about the quite odd contents of this message. However, I am convinced that most of our subscribers have enough common sense to see the difference between sane and insane. This message by Bob Smith (is this a real name..?) could have been subject to my possibility to censor messages. In this case I have chosen not to behave as censor. I hate to do that anyway. I must admit that my decision to forward mr. Smith's message may have been wrong. What is worse: forwarding messages with strange contents or censor messages?
best regards
Ton
From: LayneCnslt@cs.com
Date: Thu, 9 Sep 1999 21:30:19 EDT
Subject: IFCPP Announcement
To: TonCremers@museum-security.org
The following is a description of events and programs at the First Annual Conference, Seminar, and Exhibits of the International Foundation for Cultural Property Protection. A conference registration form is included. Attendees are expected from across the U.S., Canada, and Europe. For a detailed program schedule, contact IFCPP Executive Director, Rob Layne: Rob@IFCPP.com.
description of events and programs available at:
http://museum-security.org/ifcpp-conference-1999.htm
Smithsonian Given Historic Asian Art Trove
By Tim Loughran
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A world class collection of ancient Chinese artifacts, which once filled a small apartment in New Jersey, has been donated to a premier Asian art museum in Washington, officials said Thursday.
Worth an estimated $60 million, the 5,000-piece trove was donated to the Smithsonian's Arthur M. Sackler Gallery of Asian Art by Paul Singer, the Arthur M. Sackler Foundation and Sackler's family, museum officials confirmed.
Singer and Sackler both were psychiatrists and Chinese art experts. Singer died in 1997. Sackler died in 1987. Museum officials are in the midst of examining the collection and have no plans to mount a complete exhibition, said Susan Bliss, a Sackler Gallery spokeswoman. Some items are displayed in the museum's lobby. The collection, including ceremonial bronze bells, household containers, ceramic funeral urns, and carved jade, filled every shelf, drawer, cabinet and closet of Singer's two-bedroom apartment in Summit, New Jersey. Singer's biggest contribution to Chinese art appreciation and scholarship, experts say, is the extensive number of ceramic and bronze pieces made during the Chu Dynasty, the kingdom that dominated southern China for 500 years from the eighth to the third centuries B.C. ``We are only now learning that the art of (ancient) southern China was in many respects the equal of anything found elsewhere,'' in other parts of China from more modern imperial dynasties, said Thomas Lawton, a former director of the Sackler gallery who has studied Singer's collection extensively. Also, a large number of Singer's pieces were made by working- and middle-class families of the era, an unusual focus for serious Chinese art collectors of the 20th century, said Jenny F. So, the museum's main curator of ancient Chinese art. ``Most collected art is the product of elite societies, of royalty,'' she said. ``Paul's collection shows us for the first time how many of the common people in the Chu dynasty may have lived.'' Born in Vienna and a refugee from Nazi persecution, Singer was captivated by Chinese art as a boy. After arriving in the U.S. in the late 1930s, he visited galleries and auctions almost every weekend in search of another treasure. In fact, Singer made just one, two-week trip to China, in 1980 said Lawton. ``Remember, as Americans, it was very difficult to travel to China,'' during the decades of Cold War tension, Lawton said.
Russians rebuilding 'Amber Chamber' known as 'Eighth Wonder of the World'
By GARETH JONES
TSARSKOYE SYELO, Russia (September 9, 1999 11:00 p.m. EDT http://www.nandotimes.com) - Russia's Amber Chamber was known as the Eighth Wonder of the World until the Nazis carted it off to Germany during World War II. More than half a century later, the famed gleaming panels of "northern gold" are still missing but Russian craftsmen are rushing to rebuild the room in all its original Baroque splendour, with a little help from the old enemy. Russia's cash-strapped Culture Ministry has just signed a funding deal worth $3.5 million with Germany's Ruhrgas AG to help speed up and complete the reconstruction of the chamber. Housed in the Yekaterinsky Palace outside Russia's former imperial capital of St Petersburg, the room is meant to be completed by 2003, the 300th anniversary of the city's founding. "The Amber Room is one of the great monuments of world culture and also a symbol of the huge cultural losses suffered by Russia during World War II," Culture Minister Vladimir Yegorov told reporters before this week's signing ceremony. "This agreement (with Ruhrgas) is a pioneering project for German and Russian relations," Yegorov said. Amber chamber mirrors complex Russo-German relationship The chamber, which covers 1,080 square feet and was inlaid with six tons of exquisitely crafted amber and Italian mosaics, closely mirrors the tumultuous history of relations between Russia and Germany. Built by German craftsmen, the original Amber Chamber was sent as a gift to Russian Tsar Peter the Great from Prussia's King Frederick William I in 1716. Peter's daughter, Tsarina Elizabeth, later had the room assembled in her newly built palace in the village of Tsarskoye Syelo, 15 miles south of St Petersburg, where it remained until the German army invaded Russia in 1941. The Russians managed to rescue many of the precious furnishings from the room, including amber jewelry boxes and tables, but the Nazis seized the panels and shipped them off in 27 crates to the German city of Koenigsberg in East Prussia. The Amber Chamber was last seen in 1945, shortly before advancing Soviet troops took Koenigsberg and renamed it Kaliningrad. It remains a Russian city to this day. Both Russians and Germans have spent decades searching for the chamber. Some experts believe it was destroyed by bombs in 1945 but many more think its panels were hidden, perhaps in a mine or underground bunker. Two years ago, German police found a mosaic belonging to the Amber Chamber but nothing more has since come to light.
Restitution of looted treasures still a thorny issue
If the panels were ever found, they might well reignite simmering tensions between Moscow and Berlin over the restitution of a large number of looted artifacts. The Amber Chamber tops Russia's list of treasures missing because of the Nazi occupation but Germany is equally keen to retrieve valuable items seized by Soviet troops in 1945. These include French Impressionist paintings, drawings by Rembrandt, a rare Gutenberg Bible and gold artifacts believed to be from the ancient site of Troy. Germany was dismayed by a recent ruling by Russia's Constitutional Court upholding Moscow's right to hold on to treasures taken from Nazi Germany. The same ruling acknowledged the right of Allied governments and victims of Nazism, such as Jewish collectors, to reclaim their property. President Boris Yeltsin has criticized the Constitutional Court's ruling, saying it would complicate Russia's own efforts to retrieve thousands of artefacts still held abroad. But the Russians have long despaired of ever finding, let alone repatriating, the Amber Chamber panels. Ruhrgas cash gives big boost to reconstruction effort
As long ago as 1979, the then Soviet government made the decision to rebuild the chamber at Tsarkoye Syelo with the help of photographs of the original taken before the German invasion. Over the past 20 years the Russian craftsmen have been able to reconstruct about 40 percent of the chamber using amber mined from the Yantarny district near the Baltic Sea. But the project has been dogged by financial difficulties since the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 and so the Ruhrgas sponsorship has come as a godsend. "We need another four tons of amber to complete the room. The money from Ruhrgas puts us back on track to present the new Amber Room as a gift to St Petersburg in 2003," said Boris Igalov, who heads the team of 30 restorers. The money will help buy the amber and pay workers' wages. Yeltsin has signed a decree exempting Ruhrgas's donation from onerous taxes and customs duties. The donation is one of the biggest by a private company in Russian history and partly reflects Ruhrgas's own close links with the country, where it owns a stake in Russia's natural gas monopoly Gazprom. Ruhrgas's Chief Executive Friedrich Spaeth dismissed a reporter's suggestion that the donation had anything to do with German guilt for the devastation wrought by the Nazis in World War II, when an estimated 28 million Soviet citizens perished. "With this donation we want to look to the future, not back to the past," he said. "After all, the Amber Room is a wonderful symbol of a time when friendship between Russia and Germany was an example to the world," he said, referring to the era of Peter the Great. Spaeth also shrugged off a suggestion that money allocated to the project might be siphoned off by corrupt bureaucrats. The signing of the Amber Chamber deal coincides with claims that Russian officials and businessmen were involved in a suspected international money-laundering scam worth billions of dollars. "You need have no worry about misuse of funds. This is a matter not even worth discussing," said Spaeth.
http://www2.nando.net/noframes/story/0,2107,91380-144711-1012822-0,00.html
Buddha heads roll in theft from Cambodia's ancient temples
By DAVID LAMB in Siem Reap
Thai police had good reason to be suspicious of the 10-wheel truck that lumbered across the Cambodian border, headed for their capital, Bangkok. For one thing, the two men in the cab looked dust-covered, as if they had been working in a quarry. For another, the truck was carrying such a heavy load that its tyres were nearly flat. What the police found inside was a priceless treasure: an entire sandstone wall from the 10th-century Banteay Chhmar temple in a remote corner of north-west Cambodia. It had been skillfully cut into 119 pieces, each carefully numbered for eventual reassembly. The devastation of the temple was another sad reminder that the ancient temples of Cambodia - particularly those in the Angkor Wat complex - are under siege by gangs of organised bandits that often include army soldiers and top military brass. Most of the ancient relics find their way to shops in Bangkok frequented by Western collectors. Although pillaging is nearly as old as the temples themselves, antiquity specialists say the theft of Buddha heads, lintels, bas-reliefs and sandstone walls has reached epidemic levels in recent months, partly because of the regional economic crisis. Police say about 10 freelance gangs work in the 39-square-kilometre Angkor area. Until Angkor was occupied by the Thais in 1431 and eventually abandoned, the city was the seat of power of the Khmer Empire, whose influence stretched over half of South-East Asia for several centuries. Its complex of palaces and temples is often compared in splendor to Machu Picchu, Peru's "lost" Incan city. The Angkor temples are off limits between sunset and dawn but bandits have little difficulty entering the complex at night - despite the presence of 400 temple guards, who are sometimes paid to look the other way. The bandits know exactly what ancient piece they are after, investigators say. "It's like cutting a diamond," said Uong Von, the Siem Reap representative for the Antiquities Department. "If the stone cracks or splinters, the piece is going to lose its value. These people have skill, and they know what they are doing. "And certainly there's no doubt that top [military] brass are involved." Throughout the Angkor complex, hundreds of headless or limbless statues stand as silent symbols of the looting and destruction that have taken place here since 1860, when Henri Mouhot discovered the forgotten city of Angkor. Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge guerilla army, which ran Cambodia from 1975 to 1979, used stolen Angkor antiquities to help finance its war. The Vietnamese army that overthrew Pol Pot stole so much from Angkor that the booty was often spirited away in armoured personnel carriers. And now some members of the Cambodian Army have become so bold in pillaging the temples that they don't even bother to change out of their uniforms when stealing. Officials at Aspara Authority, the government agency that oversees the Angkor temples, said four temples in the complex had been pillaged in recent months. At least 40 items were stolen, ranging from Buddha heads no bigger than a doughnut to bas-reliefs weighing up to 130 kilograms or more. Investigators say the pillaging is mostly financed by Thai businessmen. They contract with Cambodian brokers, who make arrangements with the appropriate Cambodian army officers and temple guards. The men who do the actual cutting and chiselling may make only $A7.50 to $A15 for a piece that could eventually fetch thousands of dollars.
- Los Angeles Times
http://www.smh.com.au/news/9909/07/text/world11.html
Friday September 10 11:46 AM ET
Rembrandt Found After Reward Raised
COPENHAGEN, Denmark (AP) - The museum from which paintings by Rembrandt and Giovanni Bellini were stolen this year had to quintuple its original reward offer in order to recover them, a spokesman said Friday.
The Nivaagaard Collection museum initially offered a reward of $50,000 for information leading to the recovery of the two paintings after they were stolen in January. But the museum eventually paid $286,000 to get the paintings back last month. At one point, ``we got a hint about the whereabouts of the paintings,'' said Ebbe Simonsen, a spokesman for the private museum north of Copenhagen. ``But a larger reward was needed.'' Last month, police arrested two men in Copenhagen as they were negotiating to sell the paintings. The reward money was paid to four persons, including ``a middleman'' in an unnamed European country, Simonsen said.
The small museum near Hoersholm, 15 miles north of Copenhagen, focuses on 16th and 17th century art. The two paintings were not protected by alarms or surveillance systems.
Rare Van Gogh steps on to the open market
BY ROBIN YOUNG
A LITTLE-KNOWN sister picture to a Vincent van Gogh on loan to the National Gallery from the Van Gogh museum in Amsterdam is to be sold. The picture, A Pair of Shoes, is one of five studies of heavily worn footwear that Van Gogh painted in 1886 or 1887 while living in Rue Lepic in Montmartre, Paris. It is being sold by Christie's on behalf of a Belgian collector and is one of a scant few Van Goghs still likely to come on the market. In view of this, Christie's estimate on the picture, at UKP.1.2 to UKP.1.6 million, seems modest. Jussi Pylkkänen, Christie's director, said: "There are no precedents for the sale of a picture like this. The highly colourful pictures from the South of France have more glamour, and this has a different appeal." The painting, which has not been seen in public since 1947, originally belonged to Albert Aurier, a French writer and critic who was the first significant figure to identify Van Gogh's talent. Writing in the Mercure de France in January 1890, six months before Van Gogh's suicide, Aurier wrote of "the ingenuity of his concepts" and continued: "This robust and true artist, with the brutal hands of a giant, with the nerves of a hysterical woman, with the soul of a mystic, so original and so alone in the midst of the pitiful art of our time." It is known that Van Gogh wrote to thank Aurier and sent him a landscape in gratitude. The writer and critic collected at least six paintings by Van Gogh. The bulk of his collection was sold in 1914 and formed the core of the Van Gogh collection in the Krõller-Müller Museum in The Netherlands. Like the canvas in the National Gallery, A Pair of Shoes was painted over an earlier work. There is a confidently signed "Vincent" in bright red, which Mr Pylkkänen interprets as showing that the artist was well pleased with the work. The painting will be shown at Christie's in London in the first week of December.
(Times of London)
Main Indexpage